dreampiler/kandev
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues 43 Pull Requests Actions 6 Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

[상류 1단계] 기존 #4670 현재 main 충돌 정합 #221

New Issue
Closed
opened 2026-10-30 12:35:06 +09:00 by dreampiler · 4 comments
dreampiler commented 2026-10-30 12:35:06 +09:00
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

원 요구·승인

사용자 직접 지시(2026-10-30 03:25 KST): 기존 PR 충돌 수정 → 현재 main과 충돌하는 파일만 해결, 좁은 관련 검증, 변경분 검토 → 93/유일 5d same PR FF·public readback. 기존 기능·이력 보존, 중복 PR 0. 이 task는 #4670 현재 main 충돌 1건만 맡는 단일 source다. 기존 8e task 00dc06db-42c9-43e0-b58d-2ef274c75309(KANDEV-NW1022-K01)는 작업 사본이 'not a git repository'라 재진입할 수 없어(운영 root 확인, recovery.get null), 그 폴더는 보존하고 이 새 사본에서 같은 PR을 이어 간다. Codex 사본 D:/260720_Ai_Workspace_Tools/kandev-claude-pr-office-run-settlement(10-28 이후 수정 0)도 쓰지 않는다.

입력

kdlbs/kandev#4670 'fix(office): settle, resolve, and confirm Office runs before replacing them' OPEN/CONFLICTING, 공개 head 933d313a5f10b207da6256462a7a3b5be01065f1(fork dreampiler branch claude/pr-office-run-settlement). 8e merge-tree(main ad5cd35e7ec0 기준) 충돌 5 files: apps/backend/internal/common/config/config.go, apps/backend/internal/office/service/event_subscribers.go, apps/backend/internal/profiles/profiles.yaml, apps/backend/internal/runtimeflags/registry.go, apps/web/lib/state/slices/features/types.ts.

할 일

  1. 자기 Native 사본에 fork branch 공개 head 933d313a5f10을 가져와 확인한다. 시작 전 live PR head와 commit 작성자를 다시 읽고, 더 새 maintainer commit이 있으면 그 위에서 한다. merge-base·main·remote·public head와 실제 충돌 파일을 Plan에 기록.
  2. 현재 upstream main을 normal merge commit으로 합치고(rebase·amend·reset·force 0), 충돌 hunk만 양쪽 동작을 보존해 해결한다.
  3. 수락 기준: git diff --name-only HEAD가 PR 원 범위(git diff --name-only 933d313a5f10)의 부분집합이고 범위 밖 파일은 main과 완전히 같다. 파일별 변경이 PR 원 diff와 같은 의미다. 그 대조를 보고에 넣는다.
  4. 바뀐 package의 좁은 go test·gofmt·vet, web 파일이 있으면 lint·type check, normal hooks(Git bash를 PATH 앞에, 공용 golangci-lint 잠금: 남의 process kill·lock 삭제 0, --no-verify 0), validateCoverage.
  5. merge delta만 gate workflow rv-run 1회.
  6. 결과(새 head, merge commit, 범위 대조, 충돌 해결 요지, 검증·RV verdict)를 8e/current 96e9d7f4-0840-479a-b7b6-3e18d45b4da4에 1회.

경계

git push·gh pr 쓰기·댓글·resolve는 이 task에서 절대 하지 않는다(공개는 8e 수락 뒤 93→5d만). 새 test 파일 0, 운영·모델순서·WIP·설정 변경 0. #4712 source(1a01c947)와 같은 파일(config.go·profiles.yaml·registry.go·types.ts가 겹칠 수 있음) 동시 쓰기는 다른 branch라 무방하지만, 충돌 해결 방식이 서로 다르면 8e에 알린다.

## 원 요구·승인 사용자 직접 지시(2026-10-30 03:25 KST): 기존 PR 충돌 수정 → 현재 main과 충돌하는 파일만 해결, 좁은 관련 검증, 변경분 검토 → 93/유일 5d same PR FF·public readback. 기존 기능·이력 보존, 중복 PR 0. 이 task는 #4670 현재 main 충돌 1건만 맡는 단일 source다. 기존 8e task 00dc06db-42c9-43e0-b58d-2ef274c75309(KANDEV-NW1022-K01)는 작업 사본이 'not a git repository'라 재진입할 수 없어(운영 root 확인, recovery.get null), 그 폴더는 보존하고 이 새 사본에서 같은 PR을 이어 간다. Codex 사본 D:/260720_Ai_Workspace_Tools/kandev-claude-pr-office-run-settlement(10-28 이후 수정 0)도 쓰지 않는다. ## 입력 kdlbs/kandev#4670 'fix(office): settle, resolve, and confirm Office runs before replacing them' OPEN/CONFLICTING, 공개 head 933d313a5f10b207da6256462a7a3b5be01065f1(fork dreampiler branch claude/pr-office-run-settlement). 8e merge-tree(main ad5cd35e7ec0 기준) 충돌 5 files: apps/backend/internal/common/config/config.go, apps/backend/internal/office/service/event_subscribers.go, apps/backend/internal/profiles/profiles.yaml, apps/backend/internal/runtimeflags/registry.go, apps/web/lib/state/slices/features/types.ts. ## 할 일 1. 자기 Native 사본에 fork branch 공개 head 933d313a5f10을 가져와 확인한다. 시작 전 live PR head와 commit 작성자를 다시 읽고, 더 새 maintainer commit이 있으면 그 위에서 한다. merge-base·main·remote·public head와 실제 충돌 파일을 Plan에 기록. 2. 현재 upstream main을 normal merge commit으로 합치고(rebase·amend·reset·force 0), 충돌 hunk만 양쪽 동작을 보존해 해결한다. 3. 수락 기준: git diff --name-only <main> HEAD가 PR 원 범위(git diff --name-only <merge-base> 933d313a5f10)의 부분집합이고 범위 밖 파일은 main과 완전히 같다. 파일별 변경이 PR 원 diff와 같은 의미다. 그 대조를 보고에 넣는다. 4. 바뀐 package의 좁은 go test·gofmt·vet, web 파일이 있으면 lint·type check, normal hooks(Git bash를 PATH 앞에, 공용 golangci-lint 잠금: 남의 process kill·lock 삭제 0, --no-verify 0), validateCoverage. 5. merge delta만 gate workflow rv-run 1회. 6. 결과(새 head, merge commit, 범위 대조, 충돌 해결 요지, 검증·RV verdict)를 8e/current 96e9d7f4-0840-479a-b7b6-3e18d45b4da4에 1회. ## 경계 git push·gh pr 쓰기·댓글·resolve는 이 task에서 절대 하지 않는다(공개는 8e 수락 뒤 93→5d만). 새 test 파일 0, 운영·모델순서·WIP·설정 변경 0. #4712 source(1a01c947)와 같은 파일(config.go·profiles.yaml·registry.go·types.ts가 겹칠 수 있음) 동시 쓰기는 다른 branch라 무방하지만, 충돌 해결 방식이 서로 다르면 8e에 알린다.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-30 14:49:44 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

KANDEV-UPSTREAM-4670-MAIN-CONFLICT-20261030 progress (source)

Status: conflict-resolution preparation complete; local candidate accepted by 8e; publication pending with existing owner.

  • Worktree: C:\Users\dream.kandev\tasks\kandev-upstream-4670_rdrerlco\kandev; branch kd/upstream-4670-main-merge-20261030; HEAD b1cfbaa8a5808fe7d7abd71238454720aee140f7 (normal merge of public 933d313a5f10 + main edebfa5241c); tree 74869cc70eaa.
  • Scope: main..HEAD = 32 files = original PR scope; outside-scope 0; merged stat 32 files +2243/-75 = original PR stat; diff --check clean. 20 files byte-identical to 933; 7 auto-merged with PR hunk reproduced; 5 conflict files resolved by keeping both sides (OpenCode plugin flag + OfficeAgentErrorSessionVerdict; event_subscribers keeps main ceiling-replay settlement + PR parked-session/verdict settlement; handleTasklessAgentReady reference removed by main rename).
  • Verification: gofmt/build/vet; office/service targeted 1.704s, orchestrator targeted 15.376s, SQLite CAS 12.081s; runtimeflags/profiles pass; lint-go-changed 0 issues; web tsc/typecheck/eslint; normal pre-commit/commit-msg hooks; validateCoverage covered (32 files, 3 work orders). Pre-existing Windows-path/flake failures reproduced identically on unmodified main; not attributed to this merge.
  • RV: workflow.rv-run 1 (CALL-20261030-9aba2c492ffc): REQUEST_CHANGES, finding = recheckPendingAgentFailure applies failure on session read error vs AC-OFFICE-RUN-SETTLE-003.6. The 3 affected files (agent_error_session_verdict.go, requirements, system-design) have diff 0 from public 933 to b1cfbaa, so this is a pre-existing PR contract inconsistency, not a merge regression. 8e accepted the conflict-scope candidate and kept the finding as #4670 original-review remainder; no Office/AC/design/test changes were made here and RV was not re-run or reported PASS.
  • Publication: handed to root 8e for normal non-force 93 -> 5d same-PR FF/readback. This source did not push, open PRs, comment, resolve, merge, or change operations. Local branch/worktree/head preserved. Whole-flow close not done.
# KANDEV-UPSTREAM-4670-MAIN-CONFLICT-20261030 progress (source) Status: conflict-resolution preparation complete; local candidate accepted by 8e; publication pending with existing owner. - Worktree: C:\Users\dream\.kandev\tasks\kandev-upstream-4670_rdrerlco\kandev; branch kd/upstream-4670-main-merge-20261030; HEAD b1cfbaa8a5808fe7d7abd71238454720aee140f7 (normal merge of public 933d313a5f10 + main edebfa5241c); tree 74869cc70eaa. - Scope: main..HEAD = 32 files = original PR scope; outside-scope 0; merged stat 32 files +2243/-75 = original PR stat; diff --check clean. 20 files byte-identical to 933; 7 auto-merged with PR hunk reproduced; 5 conflict files resolved by keeping both sides (OpenCode plugin flag + OfficeAgentErrorSessionVerdict; event_subscribers keeps main ceiling-replay settlement + PR parked-session/verdict settlement; handleTasklessAgentReady reference removed by main rename). - Verification: gofmt/build/vet; office/service targeted 1.704s, orchestrator targeted 15.376s, SQLite CAS 12.081s; runtimeflags/profiles pass; lint-go-changed 0 issues; web tsc/typecheck/eslint; normal pre-commit/commit-msg hooks; validateCoverage covered (32 files, 3 work orders). Pre-existing Windows-path/flake failures reproduced identically on unmodified main; not attributed to this merge. - RV: workflow.rv-run 1 (CALL-20261030-9aba2c492ffc): REQUEST_CHANGES, finding = recheckPendingAgentFailure applies failure on session read error vs AC-OFFICE-RUN-SETTLE-003.6. The 3 affected files (agent_error_session_verdict.go, requirements, system-design) have diff 0 from public 933 to b1cfbaa, so this is a pre-existing PR contract inconsistency, not a merge regression. 8e accepted the conflict-scope candidate and kept the finding as #4670 original-review remainder; no Office/AC/design/test changes were made here and RV was not re-run or reported PASS. - Publication: handed to root 8e for normal non-force 93 -> 5d same-PR FF/readback. This source did not push, open PRs, comment, resolve, merge, or change operations. Local branch/worktree/head preserved. Whole-flow close not done.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-30 15:37:46 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

KANDEV-UPSTREAM-4670-MAIN-CONFLICT-20261030 follow-up B progress

Status: B (limited re-check read-error correction) implemented, verified, and reviewed; local candidate returned to the existing publication owner. No push/PR/comment/resolve/merge.

  • Base: public A head b1cfbaa8a5808fe7d7abd71238454720aee140f7 (main edebfa5241c).
  • Local candidate: 6a114883b8d6ecba92e25e3ef5db17b75f74626a, parent chain b1cfbaa -> 7fde6164d42 -> 6a114883b8d. Branch kd/upstream-4670-main-merge-20261030, worktree preserved.
  • B scope: 4 files (agent_error_session_verdict.go, existing agent_error_session_verdict_test.go, design Failure and recovery paragraph, task-03 Results line). main..HEAD remains the original 32-file PR scope.
  • Behavior: a re-check read error is not a verdict. The parked failure and run identity stay, a new bounded re-check is scheduled (no stored-timer Reset), stale callbacks return at the identity guard, a later recorded FAILED applies once, and a STARTING/clean-park successor is not failed. Flag OFF, early AgentFailed policy, schema and operations unchanged; AC 003.6 not weakened.
  • Verification: TestAgentErrorSessionVerdict 6 pass (including read-error case), race pass, vet pass, lint-go-changed 0 issues, normal hooks pass, validateCoverage covered (32 files, 3 work orders).
  • RV: first B CALL-20261030-6bf610bec94f REQUEST_CHANGES (timer Reset/stale-callback race); after fix, B-delta re-review CALL-20261030-52a54891eeb6 APPROVE, findings 0, verdict FORMAL-rv-4670-b-recheck-read-error-r2.md-1793341930433171000-11149-mid-1.
  • The B APPROVE is B-delta only. A original REQUEST_CHANGES and P2 remain history/open; no whole-PR approval or operations-ON claim.
  • Publication: local candidate handed to the current 8e primary (task 8e3eb6b7, session cd0c5763); 8e is processing the candidate. Public same-PR FF/readback remains the publication owner decision. Flow not closed.
# KANDEV-UPSTREAM-4670-MAIN-CONFLICT-20261030 follow-up B progress Status: B (limited re-check read-error correction) implemented, verified, and reviewed; local candidate returned to the existing publication owner. No push/PR/comment/resolve/merge. - Base: public A head b1cfbaa8a5808fe7d7abd71238454720aee140f7 (main edebfa5241c). - Local candidate: 6a114883b8d6ecba92e25e3ef5db17b75f74626a, parent chain b1cfbaa -> 7fde6164d42 -> 6a114883b8d. Branch kd/upstream-4670-main-merge-20261030, worktree preserved. - B scope: 4 files (agent_error_session_verdict.go, existing agent_error_session_verdict_test.go, design Failure and recovery paragraph, task-03 Results line). main..HEAD remains the original 32-file PR scope. - Behavior: a re-check read error is not a verdict. The parked failure and run identity stay, a new bounded re-check is scheduled (no stored-timer Reset), stale callbacks return at the identity guard, a later recorded FAILED applies once, and a STARTING/clean-park successor is not failed. Flag OFF, early AgentFailed policy, schema and operations unchanged; AC 003.6 not weakened. - Verification: TestAgentErrorSessionVerdict 6 pass (including read-error case), race pass, vet pass, lint-go-changed 0 issues, normal hooks pass, validateCoverage covered (32 files, 3 work orders). - RV: first B CALL-20261030-6bf610bec94f REQUEST_CHANGES (timer Reset/stale-callback race); after fix, B-delta re-review CALL-20261030-52a54891eeb6 APPROVE, findings 0, verdict FORMAL-rv-4670-b-recheck-read-error-r2.md-1793341930433171000-11149-mid-1. - The B APPROVE is B-delta only. A original REQUEST_CHANGES and P2 remain history/open; no whole-PR approval or operations-ON claim. - Publication: local candidate handed to the current 8e primary (task 8e3eb6b7, session cd0c5763); 8e is processing the candidate. Public same-PR FF/readback remains the publication owner decision. Flow not closed.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-30 16:16:20 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

8e가 지연 도착한 #4670 B 공개 결과를 실제 수용했다. 공식gh/API에서 publichead6a114883b8d6ecba92e25e3ef5db17b75f74626a/baseedeb/OPEN MERGEABLE-BLOCKED/원32files+2300-75와 본문 Policy re-check follow-up을 직접 확인했다. 5d결과와일치: b1cf→7fde6164d42→6a114 두정상commit nonforceFF, 기존A merge검토REQUEST_CHANGES를역사보존하고BdeltaAPPROVE(findings0)와구분,원AC약화0/parkedfailure·runidentity·AfterFunc·CompareAndDelete보호를명시. GraphQL에서thread8개중unresolved0,추가reply/resolve대상없음/새댓글조작0. 현재노출checks21개 모두completed-success또는skip,실패0/미완0;전체hostedE2E/PG/allmodes성공·상류merge·PR전체APPROVE주장0. source결과212de9d5-c60c-4853-927c-f7593e3882b5:agent-delivery-58da23418645ef1311fdb5b05b8ed6ab 및원Bformal52a54891eeb6는재사용/재검사0. 영구unreadable시pending유지+기존staleclaim/restart회복정책은비차단설계메모로유지,새만료정책/유저승인질문0. 남은CI·maintainer최종merge는기존93→5d몫,현재기록은실publicreceiving이며wholeflowclose/상류merge영수증이아니다.

8e가 지연 도착한 #4670 B 공개 결과를 실제 수용했다. 공식gh/API에서 publichead6a114883b8d6ecba92e25e3ef5db17b75f74626a/baseedeb/OPEN MERGEABLE-BLOCKED/원32files+2300-75와 본문 Policy re-check follow-up을 직접 확인했다. 5d결과와일치: b1cf→7fde6164d42→6a114 두정상commit nonforceFF, 기존A merge검토REQUEST_CHANGES를역사보존하고BdeltaAPPROVE(findings0)와구분,원AC약화0/parkedfailure·runidentity·AfterFunc·CompareAndDelete보호를명시. GraphQL에서thread8개중unresolved0,추가reply/resolve대상없음/새댓글조작0. 현재노출checks21개 모두completed-success또는skip,실패0/미완0;전체hostedE2E/PG/allmodes성공·상류merge·PR전체APPROVE주장0. source결과212de9d5-c60c-4853-927c-f7593e3882b5:agent-delivery-58da23418645ef1311fdb5b05b8ed6ab 및원Bformal52a54891eeb6는재사용/재검사0. 영구unreadable시pending유지+기존staleclaim/restart회복정책은비차단설계메모로유지,새만료정책/유저승인질문0. 남은CI·maintainer최종merge는기존93→5d몫,현재기록은실publicreceiving이며wholeflowclose/상류merge영수증이아니다.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-30 18:41:54 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

후속 B 완료.

  • 후보 head 6a114883b8d (base public b1cfbaa8a58): 7fde6164d42 + 6a114883b8d, B net 4파일
  • recheck read error: parked failure/run identity 보존, 새 bounded re-check(저장 timer Reset 없음), stale callback guard; recorded FAILED 1회 적용, successor 오실패 없음
  • 검증: 6 tests PASS, race/vet/lint/hooks/validateCoverage PASS
  • RV: 첫 B REQUEST_CHANGES(Reset 경쟁) → 수정 후 B delta 재검토 APPROVE, findings 0
  • A RC/P2는 역사·원 PR 잔여로 유지, 전체 PR 승인 표시 없음
  • 8e live primary(cd0c5763; 지정 96e9d7f4는 CANCELLED)에 후보 1회 보고, 공개 FF는 root 몫, source push 0
후속 B 완료. - 후보 head `6a114883b8d` (base public `b1cfbaa8a58`): `7fde6164d42` + `6a114883b8d`, B net 4파일 - recheck read error: parked failure/run identity 보존, 새 bounded re-check(저장 timer Reset 없음), stale callback guard; recorded FAILED 1회 적용, successor 오실패 없음 - 검증: 6 tests PASS, race/vet/lint/hooks/validateCoverage PASS - RV: 첫 B `REQUEST_CHANGES`(Reset 경쟁) → 수정 후 B delta 재검토 `APPROVE`, findings 0 - A RC/P2는 역사·원 PR 잔여로 유지, 전체 PR 승인 표시 없음 - 8e live primary(`cd0c5763`; 지정 `96e9d7f4`는 CANCELLED)에 후보 1회 보고, 공개 FF는 root 몫, source push 0
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Branches Tags
Labels
No items
No Label
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
dreampiler (dreampiler)
No Assignees
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: dreampiler/kandev#221
Delete Branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?