[상류] 기존 #4738 최신 main 충돌 정합 #214
Assignees
dreampiler (dreampiler)
Clear assignees
dreampiler (dreampiler)
No Assignees
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: dreampiler/kandev#214
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
Delete Branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
원 요구·승인
소유자 최신 실행 승인(sent/codex_upstream_execute_approved_sequence_1029.md) 1단계 '기존 PR 충돌 수정': 기존 PR을 검증부터 상류 반영까지, 기존 기능·이력 보존, 중복 PR 0. 이 task가 #4738 최신 main 충돌 delta의 단일 source writer다. 8e 확인: Native task·p320에 이 충돌의 기존 담당 없음(W-117 13a3a856은 fork PR360 rate-limit 규칙, W-117R 02a8fd7d는 fork 통합으로 closed — 둘 다 이 일이 아님).
입력 (운영root 14:12 확인)
kdlbs/kandev#4738 OPEN, 공개 head 99db765d82878b8faafc31d10ebaf61aa5b061c2, fork branch codex/upstream-provider-context-consumer-helper-20261023, mergeable=false(13:13에는 true). upstream main dc2d77359f101fe398255112346b60c617477162와 merge-tree 실제 content conflict 4파일: apps/backend/internal/agent/runtime/routingerr/provider_neutral_rules.go, docs/plans/provider-error-signatures/plan.md, docs/specs/agents/requirements/provider-error-signatures.md, docs/specs/agents/system-design/provider-error-signatures.md. 코드 충돌: #4738의 context_length_exceeded 규칙(PhasePrompt, CodeAgentRuntime 의미)과 상류 main의 structured_error_type 규칙(CodeProviderUnavailable, error label 필수)이 같은 삽입 지점을 쓴다. 옛 root source kandev-auto-pass-fix-20261023/ffd626c3는 공개 99db보다 오래됐으므로 기준으로 쓰지 않는다. 같은 git store의 과거 prepared 99db 사본들은 다른 production scratch로 바뀐 이력이 있으니 쓰지 않는다. 과거 source branch와 미반영 이력은 건드리지 않는다.
할 일
경계
PR-2 #4917·카탈로그 9066을 다시 정합하거나 일괄 재검하지 않는다. 옛 failed check 기록(4596/4747)의 403/log/rerun 재시도 0. 운영/DB/프로필/모델순서/한도/비밀·권한/설치·재시작 변경 0, force/reset/amend/branch 삭제 0, 새 상시 시험 체계 0. PG DSN 없음은 미실행 한계로 남긴다.
Result: #4738 current-main conflict reconciliation prepared. Local head 375580b02c3c34d98d7b753a3bc7c03cb5f7bce8, parents 99db765d82878b8faafc31d10ebaf61aa5b061c2 (public PR head) and dc2d77359f101fe398255112346b60c617477162 (upstream main at merge); base dc2d7735; merge base af5b46e. Reproduced exactly 4 content conflicts (merge-tree tree e3304bd): routingerr/provider_neutral_rules.go, plans/provider-error-signatures/plan.md, specs/agents/requirements/provider-error-signatures.md, specs/agents/system-design/provider-error-signatures.md. Kept both rule families (context_length prompt-send-only with phase guard; structured_error_type before generic unavailable) plus the shared catalogue, and both docs sections; corrected only cross-references that became false after the merge. Verification: routingerr TestClassify* pass (full package only fails the pre-existing Windows-only remediate fixture), orchestrator exact-consumer tests pass, gofmt clean, pr-docs validateCoverage covered (19 files), normal commit hooks pass with no bypass. Formal RV: workflow rv-run CALL-20261029-aa9a35b60236, verdict FORMAL-rv-reconciliation-delta.md-1793262576958084800-11263-mid-1 = APPROVE, findings 0, coverage 4/4, reviewer qwen lineage vs implementer deepseek; artifact _UserHub/_task/kandev-upstream-4738-main-conflict-20261029/rv-reconciliation-delta.md. No push/PR/comment per the task boundary; the non-force update of the same #4738 head remains with the publication owner (93/5d), which should re-check merge-tree before pushing 375580b0. Limitation: PostgreSQL DSN absent, PG-backed tests unrun.
8e receiving acceptance: ACCEPT #4738 current-main conflict reconciliation (task 6c2efb5a-c449-4e4a-ab8b-aca09cb4382e, single writer). 8e read-only checks: worktree kandev-upstream-4738_jgqs6ebj branch feature/kandev-upstream-4738-r3i HEAD 375580b02c3c34d98d7b753a3bc7c03cb5f7bce8, clean, a merge commit with parents public #4738 head 99db765d82878b8faafc31d10ebaf61aa5b061c2 and upstream main dc2d77359f101fe398255112346b60c617477162 (descendant of 99db, so a non-force fast-forward of the public branch codex/upstream-provider-context-consumer-helper-20261023 is possible; no rebase/amend/force). PR diff against main is 19 files; routingerr/provider_neutral_rules.go keeps both provider.context_length_exceeded.v1 (prompt-send phase guard) and main's provider.structured_error_type.v1; test changes are in existing files signature_rules_test.go and dynamic_unclassified_fallback_test.go (new production file provider_catalog_rules.go is part of the original #4738 diff). 8e ran upstream pr-docs.cjs validateCoverage on the PR diff: covered, errors 0. Formal RV on the reconciliation delta: RV-RUN-rv-reconciliation-delta.md-1793262576958084800-11263-mid-1 completed APPROVE findings 0 (8e read the record; artifact _UserHub/_task/kandev-upstream-4738-main-conflict-20261029/rv-reconciliation-delta.md). Source-reported: routingerr and orchestrator exact-consumer tests, gofmt, hooks pass; source report-progress CALL-20261029-a8dad4471133. Old root scratch ffd626c3 not used. No push/comment. Publication: 93->5d non-force FF of the same #4738 to 375580b02c3c, then public head/mergeable/CI readback.
8e publication acceptance: #4738 current-main conflict reconciliation is published by sole publisher 5d as a non-force fast-forward of the same PR. 8e gh readback: kdlbs/kandev#4738 OPEN, non-draft, MERGEABLE, head 375580b02c3c34d98d7b753a3bc7c03cb5f7bce8 = reviewed head accepted in artifact-note:20261029T084703882723Z. 93/5d readback: 19 files +542/-32, inline review threads 0, push preflight main dc2d77359f10 with no merge-tree conflicts; exact-commit check-runs 14 (success 5 incl. PR documentation coverage, in progress 2 package-fork-preview and pr-walkthrough-generate, skipped 7, failures 0, action_required 0). This is not a whole-CI-green claim; no rerun. PostgreSQL-backed tests remain unrun without DSN. Maintainer review and merge remain external. Source branch/worktree preserved.
Integration/cleanup step complete; the task advanced.
gh pr merge, no branch deletion, no push (task boundarypush/PR/댓글 0).375580b02c3c34d98d7b753a3bc7c03cb5f7bce8onfeature/kandev-upstream-4738-r3i, basedc2d7735; remotecodex/upstream-provider-context-consumer-helper-20261023intentionally still at99db765d.8e3eb6b7, session96e9d7f4, queued) and recorded once on the project ledger (flow report-progressCALL-20261029-a8dad4471133); RV verdict APPROVE included.#4738head update. Tree clean, no artifacts left behind, no repeated tests/review.Current-main follow-up remains unstarted/unfinished on original6c2efb5a. 8e officialUI unarchive once succeeded12:38:54Z, GET archived_atNULL and checkout_branchfeature/kandev-upstream-4738-r3i restored; actualpreservedbranch equals currentpublic375580b02c3c34d98d7b753a3bc7c03cb5f7bce8, main838043. OldCWS C:/Users/dream/.kandev/tasks/kandev-upstream-4738_jgqs6ebj/kandev has files but no.git. NormalPlan move d4d5cc86/entry22101 applied but no newvalidsession; one documented same-task spawn returned INTERNAL_ERROR worktree directory corrupted / checkout Git metadata is missing. No actualnewSID/firstGit/code/tests/publicchange; no retry/fakeGit/clone/deletion/reset/rawDB/newtask. ExistingPlan719ea0b2 currenterror/resumecondition recorded and sameworkflow internal prerequisite hold b020 applied, entry22102; normalPlanWIP released. Existing8e/93 to operating support owns supported managed-workspace restoration; resume samePlan only after actualGitvalidity/clean3755 readback. This is not a newhumanapproval or completedconflict; original businessclosedr10 preserved, report-only no reclose/reopen. V1/7f/P5readonly work continues, model/limits/operations unchanged.
New direct recovery contract adopted: necessary normal new session/isolated checkout on SAME6c is allowed after single-writer check, not blanket session prohibition. Installedsysteminfoe215/source contracts read; normalspawn admitted2of16 then metadata-missing setup failed, distinct UIworkspace-onlyrestore attempt returned same validation failure. Exactenv83164c08/slot73c1f52d/worktreecf3fb5ca/oldCANCELLED5ab preserved, taskPlan719ea0b2 current2f27e9e3+description hasfullUUIDs/originalpath/requiredoperatoraction. ExactROslot sourcecommon D:/Tools/kandev/.git; Gitinventory has no registeredoldpath/admin, branch3755 remains. Currente215 file-preserving automaticrecovery accepts present.gitpointer/missingadmin, not marker-absent. Inventoryrepair validates existingcheckout then repairsrows only; adoption requires non-agentadmin/WFI/oldpointer; reset teardown conflicts with preservation, add_sources not slotreplacement. No fake.git/rawDB/clone/delete/reset/permission bypass or unchangedspawn retry. Operator needs supported file-preserving marker-absent rematerialization and durableclaim/CAS rebind for sameenv/slot, preservingoldfolder/snapshot/history/3755, then8e resumesnormalPlan/newvalidsession. This is actualcapability boundary not newownerapproval/globalhalt. Existingclosedr10 report-only. Shared46752/de99 actuallyrunning current2f89 twoE2Ecausal investigation andDockercheck; no duplicate task/source, V1oldverification untouched.
8e receiving acceptance of current #4738 manual-main reconciliation in the existing ready isolated copy. Actual clean normal merge5ff7a99891c46ad73afffa70b9076b3d26449665 parentspublic375580b02c3c34d98d7b753a3bc7c03cb5f7bce8+main12bb14e57979d27f0f7c5c20aff030148fa86190, original19paths+542/-32 preserved. Sole manual requirement-doc conflict retains BOTH001.7 prompt-only/emitter/catalog fences and main001.11 bounded capacity/reset/prose safeguards; same-file inline-code rewrap only. Selected parserPASS0.051/consumerPASS0.197/docscoverage19paths2orders/formatter/PR-range whitespace/normalhooksPASS; unmodified Windows cache fixture whole-package failure and incoming-main4EOF warnings retained as limits, no whole-suite/hosted pass. FormalCALL20261031-55147944a6dd completed APPROVE/findings0/missing0/3scope, FORMAL-current-main-20261031-review.md-1793376460376453400-16576-mid-1@1; actualinference17fbda0912c6/provider491062546e2a/process786398aa41de succeeded/accepted/exit0/childgone, usage19556/853. Result_ref=_UserHub/_task/kandev-upstream-4738-main-conflict-20261029/current-main-20261031-result.md plus frozen review packet16576. Existing8e solewriter used operator-provided D copy; old Native folder/session/history preserved, no newtask/session/recoveryfeature/operations or public write. Next93/sole5d same#4738 nonforceFF and exact public head/body/CI/reviewreadback. Existing closed feature history/reportonly, do not reclose/reopen or infer publication/maintainer merge from this acceptance.
8e final receiving: same PR4738 actually updated non-force to reviewed5ff7a99891c46ad73afffa70b9076b3d26449665; official PR OPEN/MERGEABLE,6commits,original19paths+542/-32, accurate body and no inline threads directly read. Formal manual-doc delta CALL-20261031-55147944a6dd APPROVE0/missing0; source result_ref=_UserHub/_task/kandev-upstream-4738-main-conflict-20261029/current-main-20261031-result.md; prior acceptance_ref=_Runtime/state/artifact/notes/20261030T161825809373Z.json. Maintainer approval request6527856604 posted once; action_required/jobs0 is not test PASS/failure. Bounded maintenance/publication accepted, old closed/r10 not reopened/reclosed, original Native folder and ready worktree/branch/history preserved. New actual review/CI/compat inputs resume same task. Separately original4889 actually MERGED16:18:18Z/current main922971904aca81254db41d753d1ed65be66d8d83; no operational change or whole-project completion.
8e local acceptance of exact16c2d5449b33b21021e3f253eea210ca1c3e148b on original4738 task6c2efb5a and valid existing isolated copy. Normalparents public5ff7+main997bc,clean/MERGE_HEAD absent,original19scope +542/-32 and all authored feature change-lines unchanged. One stream conflict composes main resumed-activity observer with PR reasoning streak-reset exclusion; tool observation stays after finalized ownership. Existing selected25top/44subPASS/package1.650s/process0 and normalapplicablehooks/commitlint attempt1PASS; no new permanenttests/fullsuite/runtime/operating change. Fresh exact30698@1793406506073972400 artifact current-main-997-16c2-review.md; CALL-20261031-f618de243585 formalAPPROVE/findings0/missing0/3scope, actualinference de1bb8f6b984/providerd85978ebb341/processd868b73148ee succeeded/process0, independentQwen usage23587/567/USD0.01411672/reportedmodelunknown/artifact_readbackempty limits. result_ref=_UserHub/_task/kandev-upstream-4738-main-conflict-20261029/current-main-997-16c2-result.md. Ready93→sole5d same4738 publicbranchcodex/upstream-provider-context-consumer-helper-20261023 freshrefs/rules/19scope/scan/result-read-before-nonforceFF/readback. Old16576review/nativefolder/Cancelled5ab/oldrefs preserved, no newtask/session/source/publicaction8e. PG/webE2E/liveprovider/hosted/upstreammerge unclaimed; originalclosedr10 progressonly/no reopen/reclose. Public still5ff7 before handoff; not publication completion.
8e final receiving: sole5d normalnonforce SAME4738 published16c2d5449b33b21021e3f253eea210ca1c3e148b from5ff7, parent independently officialPR/forkref/head/body/files/reviewreadback OPEN MERGEABLE BLOCKED/19paths+542-32/threads0/noCHANGES_REQUESTED. Currentbody exact997 merge/one stream conflict/two reasoning owners preserved; wrong catalogH5 configFAIL5/missingGochildexit prose was found and corrected bysole5d in one clause with actualsamehead readback, history/template/bot/checklist kept. THIS4738 selected25top44subGoJSON exit0/hooksattempt1PASS/exact30698delta GateAPPROVE0 remain, old5ff7checks historical and oldcachefixture/EOF limitations preserved. Backend41151010492/E2E41151010438/Frontend41151010567 action_required; docs/preview/walkthrough success or progress separate, no hosted/all-suite/upstreammerge/operatingON claim. Original6c task manualDone after actualpublicreadback, oldCancelled5ab/nongitfolder/validcopy16c2/sourcebranches/packet/receipts/rawlogs preserved, no newtask/session or8epublicwrite. Earlierlocalacceptance_ref=_Runtime/state/artifact/notes/20261031T003243766675Z.json and result_ref=current-main-997-16c2-result.md in existing UserHub task folder. Originalclosedr10 maintenanceonly/no reopen/reclose, no further tests/RV/push/bodyedit requested without newactualinput.