[상류] 기존 #4889 maintainer blocker 2건 수정 #202
Assignees
dreampiler (dreampiler)
Clear assignees
dreampiler (dreampiler)
No Assignees
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: dreampiler/kandev#202
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
Delete Branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
원 요구·승인
소유자 최신 실행 승인(sent/codex_upstream_execute_approved_sequence_1029.md): 기존 PR 리뷰 수정을 검증부터 상류 반영까지. 이 task는 #4889 제품 코드 리뷰의 단일 source writer다. 문서 coverage는 be806d6f가 이미 반영(공개 75a9131b45d)했고 그 task의 범위를 넓히지 않는다.
입력
kdlbs/kandev#4889 'fix(office): preserve blocked outcomes during automatic completion' OPEN, 공개 head 75a9131b45dca764e5f7a926d8d5415e5b081e8c, fork branch codex/upstream-office-blocked-20261028. 미해결 thread 4개. maintainer comment 6482286091은 architecture 적합·방향 질문 불필요를 확인했다. 원자료: sent/codex_upstream_tracking_delta_1029_0128.md와 0803 packet에 정확 thread/경로.
할 일
경계
공통 sqlite workflow/task 파일을 #4736/#4891 source와 동시에 쓰지 않는다(겹치면 8e에 경로를 알리고 순서를 받는다). 운영·설정 변경 0, 상시 시험 체계 0.
KANDEV-UPSTREAM-4889-REVIEW-20261029 reviewed head c916a49cb4983101b059efd7099992f3026dafce on base 75a9131b45dca764e5f7a926d8d5415e5b081e8c (local branch codex/upstream-office-blocked-20261029-fix in the shared fork object database; not pushed). Maintainer blockers fixed: automatic workflow admission reads the locked current state and rejects BLOCKED or a stale observed state before CAS rebase, delivery effect, arrival position, or updateTaskTx; applied=false is propagated so destination effects are skipped; manual/deferred/exact/WIP paths are unchanged. Regression tests live in existing files only: task_wip_cas_test.go, terminal_step_test.go, approval_gate_step_test.go, event_handlers_children_completed_turn_test.go, office_task_status_test.go, agent_delivery_workflow_outcome_test.go. First RED on the public base: CAS admission advanced a BLOCKED task; effect admission returned admitted/applied=true and recorded the effect; a stale IN_PROGRESS snapshot overwrote concurrent BLOCKED. GREEN: targeted repository/dashboard/orchestrator/task-service tests, go vet, gofmt, scripts/lint-go-changed 0 issues, normal hooks and commitlint pass. Gate RV APPROVE, upper tier, both reviewers returned (qwen3.7-plus mid, codex-cli-exec-sol6 high), call CALL-20261029-fa6836f1df9f, verdict FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4889_blockers_rv.md-1793241584815047100-50240-upper-1@1; no required findings, one non-blocking advisory on isolating the non-BLOCKED admission mismatch branch. Not run: full backend, PostgreSQL-gated concurrency tests, E2E. Handoff: public push/PR update/reply/resolve on #4889 remain with 93-to-5d; the 4 English thread reply drafts are in the task plan. No new PR, public write, config, DB, force, or reset.
8e receiving acceptance: ACCEPT KANDEV-UPSTREAM-4889-REVIEW-20261029 source unit (task e8a0ec56-b892-4f13-922d-d364ba9770a1). First reproduction on public base 75a9131b45dc: CAS admission advanced a BLOCKED task, effect admission returned applied=true and recorded the effect, and a stale IN_PROGRESS snapshot overwrote a concurrent BLOCKED (3 repository tests failed). Fix in reviewed head c916a49cb4983101b059efd7099992f3026dafce: automatic admission reads the locked current state and rejects BLOCKED or stale observed state before any CAS rebase, delivery effect, arrival position or task update, and propagates applied=false so ordinary and CAS/signal paths skip task.updated, step-entry history, target on_enter, terminal completion and parent children-completed; manual/deferred/exact/WIP paths unchanged; 10 existing files changed, no new test file. Formal RV CALL-20261029-fa6836f1df9f formal/APPROVE upper with 2 reviewers (8e and root read); one non-blocking advisory (non-BLOCKED currentState != task.State branch not isolated) kept as follow-up suggestion. Not run: full backend, PostgreSQL concurrency, E2E. Public result (root official read 12:11 KST): kdlbs/kandev#4889 head c916a49cb498, OPEN, mergeable, 19 files, 4 threads replied and resolved, PR documentation coverage SUCCESS; action_required runs remain, no full-CI/merge claim. Accepted scope: maintainer blocker fixes of existing #4889. Remaining separately: action_required runs, maintainer review/merge. No mandatory residue. Use with the source final result_ref to close only this flow.
Reflection/cleanup complete; task advanced. Reviewed commit
c916a49cb49and branch preserved; flow progress recorded once (FLOW-NOTE-...-025305071968Z) and the queue item left open for 93→5d. No merge, push, PR, or review replies were performed.8e receiving acceptance (current-head CI failure follow-up on the closed r12 flow; earlier results stay valid): ACCEPT the #4889 fix for the real CI failure TestDispatchKanbanAgentErrorTrigger_ConcurrentSameOperationLockSpansThroughCommit (run 40809981462 shard4). Source e8a0ec56 (re-entered after the operations-root unarchive; new workflow session a88e6316). Root cause by reproduction: deterministic test-fixture gap, not flake/load/time limit. c916 added UpdateTaskWithWorkflowStepAdmissionReportingApplied and updateTransitionTask prefers it; the blocking wrapper agentErrorBlockingCommitRepo embeds the concrete sqlite repository and only overrode the old method, so the first dispatch committed through the promoted new method without blocking and entered was never closed (100% failure at line 685 before the fix). Fix: a shared enterCommit helper is called from both admission entry points in the existing test file only; no timeout increase, no skip, the operation-lock-through-commit protection unchanged, production code unchanged. 8e read-only checks: worktree kandev-upstream-4889_mgtmq9gm branch codex/upstream-office-blocked-20261029-fix HEAD a1ffcc30590093aa8423dace7d1d129228b700ca, clean, one commit on public #4889 head c916a49cb498 (non-force FF possible; public head still c916), 1 file apps/backend/internal/orchestrator/event_handlers_agent_error_evaluate_only_test.go. Formal RV FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4889_cifix_rv.md-1793281085835247400-6013-mid-1 completed APPROVE findings 0 (8e read). Source-reported: target test passes (failed before), -count=20 -race pass, sibling TestDispatchKanbanAgentErrorTrigger_* and related tests pass, gofmt, lint 0, hooks pass. No push/comment. Publication: 93->5d non-force FF of the same #4889 to a1ffcc305900.
8e publication acceptance (CI fixture fix follow-up): sole publisher 5d fast-forwarded the same kdlbs/kandev#4889 from c916a49cb498 to a1ffcc30590093aa8423dace7d1d129228b700ca after a live-head and remote-branch preflight and a clean merge-tree against main 012fb3c04069 (no cherry-pick, force or new PR). 8e gh readback: OPEN, MERGEABLE, head a1ffcc305900 = fix accepted in artifact-note:20261029T134016597235Z. 5d readback: base main, review gate BLOCKED, 20 files +973/-26, 13 checks observed with 0 failed, 0 action_required, 4 in progress; PR documentation coverage not yet reported; 4 review threads still resolved. Whether the previously failing shard-4 test passes in the new CI run is not yet observed; no pass claim and no rerun. Maintainer review and merge remain external.