dreampiler/kandev
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues 43 Pull Requests Actions 6 Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

[상류] Office 공개 PR 4건 documentation coverage 실패 수정 (단일 writer·PR별 순차) #200

New Issue
Closed
opened 2026-10-29 06:13:23 +09:00 by dreampiler · 3 comments
dreampiler commented 2026-10-29 06:13:23 +09:00
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

원 요구·승인

소유자 최신 실행 승인(sent/codex_upstream_execute_approved_sequence_1029.md): 승인 제안 순서대로 기존 PR의 충돌·리뷰·CI 수정을 검증부터 상류 PR 반영까지, 기존 기능·이력 보존, 중복 PR 0. 93 배정(2026-10-29): 네 Office PR의 현재 head에서 documentation coverage가 author가 고칠 수 있는 실패로 나왔다(403 gate 아님). maintainer 재실행 요청 0.

대상(현재 공개 head·실패 job — 93/root 제공)

  • #4889 head d988676075b753f69a9e7b96dad0baf51d1601ca, branch codex/upstream-office-blocked-20261028, job 122702192810 / run 40654511889
  • #4890 head 75e7c3f7e15fa5e04b7bb1ad24e2e8fe054ecfbb, branch codex/upstream-office-role-repair-20261028, job 122757965970 / run 40671157150
  • #4891 head 57c33d295741a6c2933852e8999fe1f8d5e07a8f, branch codex/upstream-office-trigger-edit-20261028, job 122705347204 / run 40655475575
  • #4893 head 56817294d4027cb010579fc9948e3aedaaa9e1c5, branch codex/upstream-archived-completion-20261028, job 122722680164 / run 40660688634 (#4893 preview job 122723048675 / run 40660688713은 별도 인프라 실패라 범위 밖)
    8e 읽기: 운영 root의 기존 사본 D:/260720_Ai_Workspace_Tools/kandev-wt-upstream-office-{blocked,role-repair,trigger-edit}-20261028, kandev-wt-upstream-archived-completion-20261028 는 각각 위 head에 clean. p320 queue와 활성 개발 task에 이 네 PR의 source 담당은 없다(#4893은 P43 준비 카드 54c4d469의 제출물이지만 그 wrapper는 미착수). 이 task가 단일 source writer다.

할 일 (한 번에 한 PR, 순차)

  1. 자기 Native 새 사본에서 해당 fork branch의 공개 head를 가져온다. 운영 root 사본·공용 checkout·다른 활성 branch에는 쓰지 않는다.
  2. 먼저 #4889 한 건부터: 실패 job 로그와 상류의 linked-work-order/doc-coverage 규칙(.github/scripts/pr-docs.cjs 등 현재 main 기준)을 읽어 무엇이 빠졌는지 확정한다. 실제 동작·시험·spec과 대조해, 기존 initiative/task 문서 연결과 검증 근거만 최소로 보완한다. 새 검증 체계·광범위 제품 시험 0. 같은 PR에 이미 있는 검토된 리뷰 수정 delta가 있으면 그 위에 이어 붙인다.
  3. 새 commit(force/reset/amend 0), normal hooks, 그 PR의 바뀐 delta만 gate workflow rv-run(작업공간 상대 artifact packet).
  4. 검토된 head·바뀐 파일·확인 결과를 8e/current 96e9d7f4-0840-479a-b7b6-3e18d45b4da4에 1회. 공개 갱신은 93→5d가 같은 PR에 한다.
  5. 다음 PR(#4890 → #4891 → #4893)도 같은 방식으로 하나씩. 공통 docs 파일이 PR 사이에 겹치면 PR별 branch에서만 쓰고, 같은 시간에 두 PR을 섞지 않는다.

경계

기존 미해결 리뷰 thread 15개와 원 source 소유는 보존한다. 이 단위는 documentation coverage 수정이 범위이며, thread 수정은 실제 재현 결함일 때만 같은 PR delta에 더하고 그 근거를 남긴다. 운영·설정·자격·배포 변경 0, 새 PR 0, 상시 시험 체계 0.

## 원 요구·승인 소유자 최신 실행 승인(sent/codex_upstream_execute_approved_sequence_1029.md): 승인 제안 순서대로 기존 PR의 충돌·리뷰·CI 수정을 검증부터 상류 PR 반영까지, 기존 기능·이력 보존, 중복 PR 0. 93 배정(2026-10-29): 네 Office PR의 현재 head에서 documentation coverage가 author가 고칠 수 있는 실패로 나왔다(403 gate 아님). maintainer 재실행 요청 0. ## 대상(현재 공개 head·실패 job — 93/root 제공) - #4889 head d988676075b753f69a9e7b96dad0baf51d1601ca, branch codex/upstream-office-blocked-20261028, job 122702192810 / run 40654511889 - #4890 head 75e7c3f7e15fa5e04b7bb1ad24e2e8fe054ecfbb, branch codex/upstream-office-role-repair-20261028, job 122757965970 / run 40671157150 - #4891 head 57c33d295741a6c2933852e8999fe1f8d5e07a8f, branch codex/upstream-office-trigger-edit-20261028, job 122705347204 / run 40655475575 - #4893 head 56817294d4027cb010579fc9948e3aedaaa9e1c5, branch codex/upstream-archived-completion-20261028, job 122722680164 / run 40660688634 (#4893 preview job 122723048675 / run 40660688713은 별도 인프라 실패라 범위 밖) 8e 읽기: 운영 root의 기존 사본 D:/260720_Ai_Workspace_Tools/kandev-wt-upstream-office-{blocked,role-repair,trigger-edit}-20261028, kandev-wt-upstream-archived-completion-20261028 는 각각 위 head에 clean. p320 queue와 활성 개발 task에 이 네 PR의 source 담당은 없다(#4893은 P43 준비 카드 54c4d469의 제출물이지만 그 wrapper는 미착수). 이 task가 단일 source writer다. ## 할 일 (한 번에 한 PR, 순차) 0. 자기 Native 새 사본에서 해당 fork branch의 공개 head를 가져온다. 운영 root 사본·공용 checkout·다른 활성 branch에는 쓰지 않는다. 1. 먼저 #4889 한 건부터: 실패 job 로그와 상류의 linked-work-order/doc-coverage 규칙(.github/scripts/pr-docs.cjs 등 현재 main 기준)을 읽어 무엇이 빠졌는지 확정한다. 실제 동작·시험·spec과 대조해, 기존 initiative/task 문서 연결과 검증 근거만 최소로 보완한다. 새 검증 체계·광범위 제품 시험 0. 같은 PR에 이미 있는 검토된 리뷰 수정 delta가 있으면 그 위에 이어 붙인다. 2. 새 commit(force/reset/amend 0), normal hooks, 그 PR의 바뀐 delta만 gate workflow rv-run(작업공간 상대 artifact packet). 3. 검토된 head·바뀐 파일·확인 결과를 8e/current 96e9d7f4-0840-479a-b7b6-3e18d45b4da4에 1회. 공개 갱신은 93→5d가 같은 PR에 한다. 4. 다음 PR(#4890 → #4891 → #4893)도 같은 방식으로 하나씩. 공통 docs 파일이 PR 사이에 겹치면 PR별 branch에서만 쓰고, 같은 시간에 두 PR을 섞지 않는다. ## 경계 기존 미해결 리뷰 thread 15개와 원 source 소유는 보존한다. 이 단위는 documentation coverage 수정이 범위이며, thread 수정은 실제 재현 결함일 때만 같은 PR delta에 더하고 그 근거를 남긴다. 운영·설정·자격·배포 변경 0, 새 PR 0, 상시 시험 체계 0.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-29 07:42:18 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

2026-10-29 documentation-coverage unit: four existing upstream PRs reviewed. Final source heads (not pushed by this task): #4889 75a9131b45d (base d988676), #4890 942bd378442 (base 75e7c3f), #4891 30da9e8a5c5 (base 57c33d2; three docs commits after two RV corrections), #4893 2edf7de5539 on current upstream head 745bf17 (two-file work-order frontmatter fix). All four have RV APPROVE from a different lineage (openai/gpt-6-luna): FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4889_doccov_rv.md-1793225713680447000-24534-mid-2, FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4890_doccov_rv.md-1793225937696646800-68728-mid-1, FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4891_doccov_rv_r3.md-1793226539200632400-33529-mid-1, FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4893_doccov_r2_rv.md-1793227038926389800-39521-mid-1. Local validateCoverage covered for each; pr-docs tests 101/101; list-docs validate and lint-spec pass; commit hooks pass. No product code, review threads, or PR metadata changed; no push or merge. #4893 head moved from task-input 5681729 to 745bf17; its changed work orders kept legacy spec: frontmatter and coverage became invalid, so the new delta replaces spec: with requirements/acceptance_criteria/system_design on both work orders. Handoff: 93->5d must push the four fast-forward refs and rerun PR documentation coverage; this flow stays open until live coverage passes. Obsolete branch docs/upstream-4893-doccov (1b8d13c230b) must not be pushed.

2026-10-29 documentation-coverage unit: four existing upstream PRs reviewed. Final source heads (not pushed by this task): #4889 75a9131b45d (base d988676), #4890 942bd378442 (base 75e7c3f), #4891 30da9e8a5c5 (base 57c33d2; three docs commits after two RV corrections), #4893 2edf7de5539 on current upstream head 745bf17 (two-file work-order frontmatter fix). All four have RV APPROVE from a different lineage (openai/gpt-6-luna): FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4889_doccov_rv.md-1793225713680447000-24534-mid-2, FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4890_doccov_rv.md-1793225937696646800-68728-mid-1, FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4891_doccov_rv_r3.md-1793226539200632400-33529-mid-1, FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4893_doccov_r2_rv.md-1793227038926389800-39521-mid-1. Local validateCoverage covered for each; pr-docs tests 101/101; list-docs validate and lint-spec pass; commit hooks pass. No product code, review threads, or PR metadata changed; no push or merge. #4893 head moved from task-input 5681729 to 745bf17; its changed work orders kept legacy spec: frontmatter and coverage became invalid, so the new delta replaces spec: with requirements/acceptance_criteria/system_design on both work orders. Handoff: 93->5d must push the four fast-forward refs and rerun PR documentation coverage; this flow stays open until live coverage passes. Obsolete branch docs/upstream-4893-doccov (1b8d13c230b) must not be pushed.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-29 10:36:15 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

8e receiving acceptance: ACCEPT KANDEV-UPSTREAM-OFFICE4-DOCCOV-20261029 documentation-coverage unit (source task be806d6f-67b2-49f6-b514-ce346a22a5e7, single writer). Original goal: fix the author-fixable PR documentation coverage failure on four Office PRs. Public result per PR (operating root official GitHub readback 2026-10-29): #4889 head 75a9131b45dca764e5f7a926d8d5415e5b081e8c, docs delta from be806, PR documentation coverage SUCCESS run 40786593060 / check 123184137879. #4890 head e280b2eba4f97b59ff2440582cd8ed279dd44f81 (compare 6c87f0df3efc..e280 ahead 3 behind 0, plan.md +76 and task-01 +103, maintainer product code and 7 resolved threads kept), coverage SUCCESS run 40799972239, exact-head checks failed 0 / pending 0; delta review RV FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4890_current_rv_r4.md-1793234020425526700-27974-mid-1 APPROVE. Record correction: be806 did not hand e280 to 5d directly (its messages went to 93 queued and 8e sent); operating root verified and delivered it to 5d once, then 5d updated the PR. #4891 head 30da9e8a5c575ad9db21fef9566ca223b0bb60dd (be806 delta with RV r3 APPROVE), coverage SUCCESS run 40786647771 / check 123185193473. #4893: the maintainer pushed a further fix f1c27137f2958409065a97a90378297ed5e3d1ee (including frontmatter); coverage SUCCESS run 40782207820 / check 123170015045; be806 candidates 1b8d13c230b and 2edf7de5539 were not pushed and are not restored — #4893 coverage success is credited to the maintainer commit, not to this source. Accepted scope: documentation coverage only. Not included and continuing separately: #4889/#4891 code-review fixes (e8a0ec56 / 61496dec), #4736 CI (fe8d3c74), P48 reviews, fork action_required runs, maintainer review/merge. No mandatory residue for this unit. Use with the source final result_ref to close only this flow.

8e receiving acceptance: ACCEPT KANDEV-UPSTREAM-OFFICE4-DOCCOV-20261029 documentation-coverage unit (source task be806d6f-67b2-49f6-b514-ce346a22a5e7, single writer). Original goal: fix the author-fixable PR documentation coverage failure on four Office PRs. Public result per PR (operating root official GitHub readback 2026-10-29): #4889 head 75a9131b45dca764e5f7a926d8d5415e5b081e8c, docs delta from be806, PR documentation coverage SUCCESS run 40786593060 / check 123184137879. #4890 head e280b2eba4f97b59ff2440582cd8ed279dd44f81 (compare 6c87f0df3efc..e280 ahead 3 behind 0, plan.md +76 and task-01 +103, maintainer product code and 7 resolved threads kept), coverage SUCCESS run 40799972239, exact-head checks failed 0 / pending 0; delta review RV FORMAL-261029_kandev_pr4890_current_rv_r4.md-1793234020425526700-27974-mid-1 APPROVE. Record correction: be806 did not hand e280 to 5d directly (its messages went to 93 queued and 8e sent); operating root verified and delivered it to 5d once, then 5d updated the PR. #4891 head 30da9e8a5c575ad9db21fef9566ca223b0bb60dd (be806 delta with RV r3 APPROVE), coverage SUCCESS run 40786647771 / check 123185193473. #4893: the maintainer pushed a further fix f1c27137f2958409065a97a90378297ed5e3d1ee (including frontmatter); coverage SUCCESS run 40782207820 / check 123170015045; be806 candidates 1b8d13c230b and 2edf7de5539 were not pushed and are not restored — #4893 coverage success is credited to the maintainer commit, not to this source. Accepted scope: documentation coverage only. Not included and continuing separately: #4889/#4891 code-review fixes (e8a0ec56 / 61496dec), #4736 CI (fe8d3c74), P48 reviews, fork action_required runs, maintainer review/merge. No mandatory residue for this unit. Use with the source final result_ref to close only this flow.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-29 10:40:12 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

FINAL RESULT — KANDEV-UPSTREAM-OFFICE4-DOCCOV-20261029 (documentation coverage only)

Public live bindings confirmed by operating root:

  • #4889 head 75a9131b45dc, run 40786593060 / check 123184137879, documentation coverage SUCCESS.
  • #4890 head e280b2eba4f9, run 40799972239; exact-head checks failed 0, pending 0; compare 6c87..e280 is ahead 3, documentation coverage SUCCESS.
  • #4891 head 30da9e8a5c57, run 40786647771 / check 123185193473, documentation coverage SUCCESS.
  • #4893 maintainer head f1c27137f295, run 40782207820 / check 123170015045, documentation coverage SUCCESS. This success is the maintainer's contribution; this source's 1b8d/2edf candidates were not published or restored.

Correction to the task record: e280 was not handed directly by this task to 5d. This task's message was queued to 93 and sent to 8e; operating root confirmed the result and delivered it once to 5d, and 5d then updated the PR. The Plan wording is corrected accordingly.

Acceptance: 8e note artifact-note:20261029T013624956570Z (same jobsheet, scope documentation coverage only).
Scope boundary: #4889/#4891 code review, #4736 CI, and P48 remain other source owners' work and are not bundled into this closure. No code/test/RV rerun, no push, and no PR comments were performed by this task.

FINAL RESULT — KANDEV-UPSTREAM-OFFICE4-DOCCOV-20261029 (documentation coverage only) Public live bindings confirmed by operating root: - #4889 head 75a9131b45dc, run 40786593060 / check 123184137879, documentation coverage SUCCESS. - #4890 head e280b2eba4f9, run 40799972239; exact-head checks failed 0, pending 0; compare 6c87..e280 is ahead 3, documentation coverage SUCCESS. - #4891 head 30da9e8a5c57, run 40786647771 / check 123185193473, documentation coverage SUCCESS. - #4893 maintainer head f1c27137f295, run 40782207820 / check 123170015045, documentation coverage SUCCESS. This success is the maintainer's contribution; this source's 1b8d/2edf candidates were not published or restored. Correction to the task record: e280 was not handed directly by this task to 5d. This task's message was queued to 93 and sent to 8e; operating root confirmed the result and delivered it once to 5d, and 5d then updated the PR. The Plan wording is corrected accordingly. Acceptance: 8e note artifact-note:20261029T013624956570Z (same jobsheet, scope documentation coverage only). Scope boundary: #4889/#4891 code review, #4736 CI, and P48 remain other source owners' work and are not bundled into this closure. No code/test/RV rerun, no push, and no PR comments were performed by this task.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Branches Tags
Labels
No items
No Label
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
dreampiler (dreampiler)
No Assignees
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: dreampiler/kandev#200
Delete Branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?