dreampiler/kandev
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues 43 Pull Requests Actions 6 Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

[KANDEV-W-109] 우리-열-림-PR-전-수-점-검-표 (rebase/충-돌/CI/리-뷰-4-축) #173

New Issue
Closed
opened 2026-10-25 01:07:06 +09:00 by dreampiler · 3 comments
dreampiler commented 2026-10-25 01:07:06 +09:00
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

queue: KANDEV-W-109

목표

운영 10-25 02:2xKST-공급-3차-①: -우리- authored- OPEN- 상류-PR- 전-수 (관-제-14:2x-실-측- 46-건: - 4045,4595,4596,4597,4599,46004605,4628,4644,4652,4662,4670,47094724,4727,4728,4730,4732~4738,4740,4746,4747,4751 —-운-영-표-기- 44-건-대-비-+#4751-등-시-점-차-본-목-록-기-준)을-4-축-으-로-점-검-해-표-1-장을-작-성-한다. -지-시-원-문: -「상류- main(0b81ae48d-이-후)을-기-준-으-로-PR-마다- rebase-필-요-여-부·충-돌·CI-상-태·리-뷰-미-응-답-을-표-로-점-검. -포크- main-이-상-류-보-다-142-뒤-라- PR- head-가-갈-라-져-있-을-가-능-성-이-큽-니-다.」

진-행 (RO-만)

  1. fork- main- ↔-상-류- main-差-분-먼-저-실-측 (운-영-제-공- 142-뒤-여-부-검-증-포-함; -merge- base-기-준- behind-수-치) —-이-후-PR-별-판-정-의-基-準-으-로-사-용.
  2. PR-별-4-축-측-정: -①rebase-필-요-여-부 (merge- base- =-fork- main-기-반-가-지-와-상-류- main-差-분; -상-류- main-대-비- behind-수-와-갈-라-짐-여-부) ②충-돌 (mergeable/merge-State-Status) ③CI-상-태 (failing-/-pending-체-크-이-름-포-함) ④리-뷰-미-응-답 (GraphQL- review- Threads- unresolved-수). -GitHub- 읽-기-전-용- API-만 (REST+GraphQL-모-두-허-용), -GitHub-쓰-기-0.
  3. 결과-표- =-PR-번호-| -re- base-필-요-|-충-돌-|-CI-실-패-·-진-행-|-리-뷰-미-응-답|-종-합-분-류 (대-응-대-상/대-기) —-본- Plan-+-부-모-보-고-양-쪽-에-기-록. -예-외-관-측 (head-소-속-저장-소-변-동-등)도-별-도-표-기 (금-일- #4744-병-렬-가-지-선-례-있-음).
  4. 판-단-·등-록-은-관-제(93c6b4d0)-몫 —-본-작-업-은-측-정-·표-작-성-까-지만 (PR-별-자-식-등-록-·기-능-코드-수-정-·push-·PR-생-성-·상-류-쓰-기-없-음).

경-계

  • RO-만: -GitHub-쓰-기·push-·PR-·이-슈-·close-·라-벨-0. -새-검-증-도-구-·상-시-시-험-없-음 (기-존- gh/GraphQL-읽-기-사-용). -재-기-동-·타-세-션-·작-업-사-본-불-요 (RO-조-사- =-projectRepo/네-트-워-크-만).-읽-기-호-출-수- (46-건-×-다-축) =-필-요-한-만-큼-허-용-하-되-부-모-보-고-시-호-출-수-요-약.
    [근-거-승-인] 운-영- 2026-10-25- 02:2x- 3차-공-급. -사-용-자-원-문 (진-단-세-션-경-유): -「kandev- 먼-저- 진-행-해-줘」-+-「상류-에-서-승-인-될-내-용-이-라-면-구-현-착-수...」 (10-24- 22:3x).
queue: KANDEV-W-109 ## 목표 운영 10-25 02:2xKST-공급-3차-①: -우리- authored- OPEN- 상류-PR- 전-수 (관-제-14:2x-실-측- 46-건: - 4045,4595,4596,4597,4599,4600~4605,4628,4644,4652,4662,4670,4709~4724,4727,4728,4730,4732~4738,4740,4746,4747,4751 —-운-영-표-기- 44-건-대-비-+#4751-등-시-점-차-본-목-록-기-준)을-4-축-으-로-점-검-해-**표-1-장**을-작-성-한다. -지-시-원-문: -「상류- main(0b81ae48d-이-후)을-기-준-으-로-PR-마다- rebase-필-요-여-부·충-돌·CI-상-태·리-뷰-미-응-답-을-표-로-점-검. -포크- main-이-상-류-보-다-142-뒤-라- PR- head-가-갈-라-져-있-을-가-능-성-이-큽-니-다.」 ## 진-행 (RO-만) 1. fork- main- ↔-상-류- main-差-분-먼-저-실-측 (운-영-제-공- 142-뒤-여-부-검-증-포-함; -merge- base-기-준- behind-수-치) —-이-후-PR-별-판-정-의-基-準-으-로-사-용. 2. PR-별-4-축-측-정: -①rebase-필-요-여-부 (merge- base- =-fork- main-기-반-가-지-와-상-류- main-差-분; -상-류- main-대-비- behind-수-와-갈-라-짐-여-부) ②충-돌 (mergeable/merge-State-Status) ③CI-상-태 (failing-/-pending-체-크-이-름-포-함) ④리-뷰-미-응-답 (GraphQL- review- Threads- unresolved-수). -GitHub- 읽-기-전-용- API-만 (REST+GraphQL-모-두-허-용), -GitHub-쓰-기-0. 3. 결과-표- =-PR-번호-| -re- base-필-요-|-충-돌-|-CI-실-패-·-진-행-|-리-뷰-미-응-답|-종-합-분-류 (대-응-대-상/대-기) —-본- Plan-+-부-모-보-고-양-쪽-에-기-록. -예-외-관-측 (head-소-속-저장-소-변-동-등)도-별-도-표-기 (금-일- #4744-병-렬-가-지-선-례-있-음). 4. 판-단-·등-록-은-관-제(93c6b4d0)-몫 —-본-작-업-은-측-정-·표-작-성-까-지만 (PR-별-자-식-등-록-·기-능-코드-수-정-·push-·PR-생-성-·상-류-쓰-기-없-음). ## 경-계 - RO-만: -GitHub-쓰-기·push-·PR-·이-슈-·close-·라-벨-0. -새-검-증-도-구-·상-시-시-험-없-음 (기-존- gh/GraphQL-읽-기-사-용). -재-기-동-·타-세-션-·작-업-사-본-불-요 (RO-조-사- =-projectRepo/네-트-워-크-만).-읽-기-호-출-수- (46-건-×-다-축) =-필-요-한-만-큼-허-용-하-되-부-모-보-고-시-호-출-수-요-약. [근-거-승-인] 운-영- 2026-10-25- 02:2x- 3차-공-급. -사-용-자-원-문 (진-단-세-션-경-유): -「kandev- 먼-저- 진-행-해-줘」-+-「상류-에-서-승-인-될-내-용-이-라-면-구-현-착-수...」 (10-24- 22:3x).
dreampiler commented 2026-10-25 01:39:47 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

[KANDEV-W-109] 우리 authored OPEN 상류 PR 46건 4축 점검 완료 (측정 2026-10-25, GitHub 읽기 전용)

  • 범위: kdlbs/kandev OPEN 100건 중 head=dreampiler 46건 전수(author=dreampiler, base=main, draft 0, head ref 로컬 SHA 불일치 0).
  • 기준선: upstream/main 0b81ae48d(10-24), fork origin/main 28aacb239(10-15), merge-base 68bad6c7, upstream-only 142 / fork-only 505 → 운영 제시 "포크 142 뒤" 확인. PR head가 fork-only 505 커밋을 포함한 경우 0건이므로 PR 내용 오염은 없음.
  • rebase: 필요 45 / 불필요 1(#4628). behind 분포 2(1) 7(4) 8(3) 9(9) 11(13) 39(1) 51(1) 60(1) 65(2) 95(9) 311(1).
  • 충돌: 3건 #4737 #4722 #4712 (mergeStateStatus DIRTY).
  • CI: 체크 실패 9건 — walkthrough 5(#4722 #4718 #4715 #4652 #4596, 로그 "walkthrough generation stopped: deadline"), docs-coverage 2(#4751 #4596, "No changed work order covers the triggering paths"), claude-review 2(#4747 #4746, is_error:true), deploy-fork 1(#4670, 업로드 HTTP 502). pending 0.
  • 핵심: 45/46은 Backend Tests·Frontend Tests·E2E Tests·Architecture Lint·Lint Harness Files·Lint Action Pinning·pr-title 등이 action_required(상류 메인테이너 승인 대기)로 미실행. 전체 CI가 실행·통과한 PR은 #4045 1건뿐이며 그 PR이 behind 311로 가장 낡음 → 상류 승인 전에는 "CI 초록"으로 판단 불가.
  • 리뷰 미응답: 미해결 스레드 1건 #4644(CodeRabbit Major, processidentity_windows.go:206, W-108 진행 중). CHANGES_REQUESTED·APPROVED·리뷰 요청 대기 모두 0.
  • 예외 관측: #4744(author app/dependabot, head kdlbs/kandev)가 우리 #4751과 같은 branch명으로 병존 — 46건 밖. #4647·#4631도 동종 상류 head.
  • 산출물: 46행 표 전문은 Kandev task 22f79649 Plan 및 관제(93c6b4d0) 보고에 기록.
  • 한계: 상류 branch protection 조회 404(관리자 권한 없음) → mergeStateStatus=BLOCKED 구체 사유 미확인.
  • 경계 준수: GitHub 쓰기·push·PR·이슈·라벨 0, 기능 코드 수정 0, 새 검증 도구·상시 시험 0, 작업공간 변경 0(git status clean).
  • 인계: PR별 대응 판단·자식 등록은 관제(93c6b4d0) 몫. 본 항목의 측정·표 작성 완료. flow 종결은 기존 reconcile/관제 판단에 맡김.
[KANDEV-W-109] 우리 authored OPEN 상류 PR 46건 4축 점검 완료 (측정 2026-10-25, GitHub 읽기 전용) - 범위: kdlbs/kandev OPEN 100건 중 head=dreampiler 46건 전수(author=dreampiler, base=main, draft 0, head ref 로컬 SHA 불일치 0). - 기준선: upstream/main 0b81ae48d(10-24), fork origin/main 28aacb239(10-15), merge-base 68bad6c7, upstream-only 142 / fork-only 505 → 운영 제시 "포크 142 뒤" 확인. PR head가 fork-only 505 커밋을 포함한 경우 0건이므로 PR 내용 오염은 없음. - rebase: 필요 45 / 불필요 1(#4628). behind 분포 2(1) 7(4) 8(3) 9(9) 11(13) 39(1) 51(1) 60(1) 65(2) 95(9) 311(1). - 충돌: 3건 #4737 #4722 #4712 (mergeStateStatus DIRTY). - CI: 체크 실패 9건 — walkthrough 5(#4722 #4718 #4715 #4652 #4596, 로그 "walkthrough generation stopped: deadline"), docs-coverage 2(#4751 #4596, "No changed work order covers the triggering paths"), claude-review 2(#4747 #4746, is_error:true), deploy-fork 1(#4670, 업로드 HTTP 502). pending 0. - 핵심: 45/46은 Backend Tests·Frontend Tests·E2E Tests·Architecture Lint·Lint Harness Files·Lint Action Pinning·pr-title 등이 action_required(상류 메인테이너 승인 대기)로 미실행. 전체 CI가 실행·통과한 PR은 #4045 1건뿐이며 그 PR이 behind 311로 가장 낡음 → 상류 승인 전에는 "CI 초록"으로 판단 불가. - 리뷰 미응답: 미해결 스레드 1건 #4644(CodeRabbit Major, processidentity_windows.go:206, W-108 진행 중). CHANGES_REQUESTED·APPROVED·리뷰 요청 대기 모두 0. - 예외 관측: #4744(author app/dependabot, head kdlbs/kandev)가 우리 #4751과 같은 branch명으로 병존 — 46건 밖. #4647·#4631도 동종 상류 head. - 산출물: 46행 표 전문은 Kandev task 22f79649 Plan 및 관제(93c6b4d0) 보고에 기록. - 한계: 상류 branch protection 조회 404(관리자 권한 없음) → mergeStateStatus=BLOCKED 구체 사유 미확인. - 경계 준수: GitHub 쓰기·push·PR·이슈·라벨 0, 기능 코드 수정 0, 새 검증 도구·상시 시험 0, 작업공간 변경 0(git status clean). - 인계: PR별 대응 판단·자식 등록은 관제(93c6b4d0) 몫. 본 항목의 측정·표 작성 완료. flow 종결은 기존 reconcile/관제 판단에 맡김.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-25 03:46:08 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

W109 receiving-controller8e acceptance: the original 46-row PR snapshot and existing source files rows2.json, details.json, own.json, runs.json were read and reconciled without a fresh GitHub scan. There are 46 unique PRs, 45 positive-behind rows, 3 conflicting PRs, 9 PRs with failing checks, 1 unresolved thread, and 45 PRs with unexecuted approval-waiting workflows in that recorded snapshot. The 93 controller Plan already consumes this table for its existing follow-up tasks. Accept only the completed read-only measurement and table unit. Positive behind is a refresh candidate, not proof that every PR requires rebase: branch-protection details remain unavailable. Check-run failures and workflow-run results are distinct observations. The snapshot is historical, not current CI or production acceptance. Native completion stays unchanged; close the original flow using the existing final result report. PR fixes and publication remain with93 and5d; upstream workflow approval remains a maintainer input. No new task, scan, code, model turn, recurring test, or GitHub write is requested.

W109 receiving-controller8e acceptance: the original 46-row PR snapshot and existing source files rows2.json, details.json, own.json, runs.json were read and reconciled without a fresh GitHub scan. There are 46 unique PRs, 45 positive-behind rows, 3 conflicting PRs, 9 PRs with failing checks, 1 unresolved thread, and 45 PRs with unexecuted approval-waiting workflows in that recorded snapshot. The 93 controller Plan already consumes this table for its existing follow-up tasks. Accept only the completed read-only measurement and table unit. Positive behind is a refresh candidate, not proof that every PR requires rebase: branch-protection details remain unavailable. Check-run failures and workflow-run results are distinct observations. The snapshot is historical, not current CI or production acceptance. Native completion stays unchanged; close the original flow using the existing final result report. PR fixes and publication remain with93 and5d; upstream workflow approval remains a maintainer input. No new task, scan, code, model turn, recurring test, or GitHub write is requested.
dreampiler commented 2026-10-25 03:46:56 +09:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

KANDEV-W-109 완료.

  • 표: 46행 4축 점검표를 Plan에 저장(충돌 2 + 충돌·CI실패 1 + CI실패 8 + 리뷰미응답 1 + 최신 1 + rebase만 33 = 46).
  • 기준선: upstream 0b81ae48d, fork 28aacb239, merge-base 68bad6c7 → 142/505 확인. PR head의 fork-only 커밋 오염은 0건.
  • 핵심: 45/46은 실질 테스트 워크플로가 action_required(상류 승인 대기)로 미실행 — "CI 초록" 판단 불가. 전체 CI 통과는 behind 311인 #4045뿐.
  • 예외: #4744(author app/dependabot, head kdlbs)가 우리 #4751과 동일 branch명으로 병존.
  • 관제 보고 발송 완료, GitHub 쓰기·코드 수정 0, 작업공간 clean.
KANDEV-W-109 완료. - **표**: 46행 4축 점검표를 Plan에 저장(충돌 2 + 충돌·CI실패 1 + CI실패 8 + 리뷰미응답 1 + 최신 1 + rebase만 33 = 46). - **기준선**: upstream `0b81ae48d`, fork `28aacb239`, merge-base `68bad6c7` → 142/505 확인. PR head의 fork-only 커밋 오염은 0건. - **핵심**: 45/46은 실질 테스트 워크플로가 `action_required`(상류 승인 대기)로 미실행 — "CI 초록" 판단 불가. 전체 CI 통과는 behind 311인 #4045뿐. - **예외**: #4744(author app/dependabot, head kdlbs)가 우리 #4751과 동일 branch명으로 병존. - 관제 보고 발송 완료, GitHub 쓰기·코드 수정 0, 작업공간 clean.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Branches Tags
Labels
No items
No Label
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
dreampiler (dreampiler)
No Assignees
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: dreampiler/kandev#173
Delete Branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?